Introduction and Background
The following lesson plan was used by a group of Conflict Analysis and Resolution Master’s and PhD Candidates for a day-long peace education workshop with a class of 8th grade students from Washington D.C. The students were a part of a U.S. History course, but had been studying peace education and the history of nonviolent conflict in their course and were interested in learning more.
The following lesson plan is broken down into three main sections: Introduction and Ice Breaker, the Counter-Rally Activity, and Exercises in Identity.
-Introduction and Ice Breaker:
- Learning the value of prototyping
- Synergizing ideas on the fly
- Working under pressure
- Students will conduct a narrative analysis of dominant political narratives
- Students will develop strategy and tactics for a political rally
- Students will identify methods and areas to express nonviolent agency
-Exercises in Identity:
- Students will learn different types of identities
- Students will pinpoint certain values that make up their identity
- Students will self-reflect on how they prioritize identities within their own lives
Total: 4.5 hours
Breakdown: Intro and Ice Breaker (45 minutes)
Counter-Rally Activity (2.5 hours)
Exercises in Identity (1 hour)
Dry erase markers/board
Computer w/ Internet connection
-Introduction and Ice Breaker:
1). Provide 20 pieces of spaghetti, 1 marshmallow, 1 yard of masking tape, 1 yard of string for each group of 4-6 participants
2). Explain the rules:
- The goal is to create the tallest freestanding structure with the marshmallow at top, which means the structure has to be standing on its own at the end of the activity without the assistance of participants or being taped down to the surface
- The marshmallow must be stuck onto the top of the spaghetti tower in its entirety, meaning it may not be split or even eaten
- The spaghetti, tape, or string may be broken up to be used at the team sees fit. The team may use as much or as little as they want.
- It may be a good idea to repeat the instructions or even have participants explain it again for the whole workshop.
3). Time is limited to 18 minutes. Depending on the need, this may be shortened, but leave enough time for the participants to actually have the opportunity to build something.
4). Start the challenge, preferably with some appropriate music.
5). In case the teams are all having a difficult time, hints can be given at set intervals, which also serve as time reminders.
6). A round of applause should be given to the team that has the tallest structure
7). Debrief Questions
- What steps did you take to build the structure? Did you talk and build at the same time or did you talk then build?
- What were some issues that arose? Can you think of some possible solutions?
- What were some observations that you made? Please elaborate
8). This activity itself should be fun and active, while the debrief should serve as a “calm down” session.
1). Screen video clip for students of Donald Trump campaign rally: http://www.nola.com/politics/index.ssf/2016/02/donald_trumps_build_that_wall.html
2). Conduct de-brief after video:
- What are your reactions to this video?
- What is Trump’s message in it?
- How does it make you feel?
- (What) had you heard about the wall before this video?
- Why do you think people support the wall? Why do you think people are opposed to it?
- What picture does he paint of people crossing into America at the US-Mexican border?
- What kind of story is he trying to tell in this speech?
- What kind of things do you think people at this rally might believe about undocumented immigrants? What words might they use to describe them? Why do you think that is?
* What images and stories of Mexican immigrants is he not including or giving voice to? Why do you think that is?
3). Pose the Situation and Project
Trump supporters are holding a rally in support of the wall. You’ve been tasked with holding a counter-rally against the wall. You have two hours on a Saturday to plan an event for that day.
You’ll be able to break up into teams to plan different parts of the rally. Allow students to choose groups, unless they’re really out-of-balance and then encourage a few volunteers to change groups.
- Messaging – What slogans, catchphrases, descriptions, language do we want to use for this rally?
- Programming – What will be happening in the rally? When will it be happening? Where? How?
- Arts/Design – How can we use creative arts to promote the rally? During the rally?
Banners, chants, songs?
- Outreach/Social Media – How are we going to turn people out? How are we going to use social media to promote the event?
Before picking groups, choose a name for the rally. If they don’t decide in the time allotted, encourage the messaging group to choose one from the current options.
Also, encourage the groups to communicate with each other to ensure that they have a collective vision for the event.
4). Independent Working Time in Groups
5). Group Collaboration on Presentation
Give the group 10 minutes to come back together as one large group and check in on their progress. Encourage them to make a plan for how they will present to the leaders and who will present.
6). Presentation to Leaders
7). Debrief the activity:
- How was this activity for you? What did you like about it, if anything? What did you not like, if anything?
- What was easy about this exercise? What was hard about this exercise?
- What are you taking away from this?
- What are some risks of this kind of activism?
- What are some opportunities that can come from this kind of activism?
-Exercises in Identity
This activity works best with even numbers, so the students can pair up. To begin, divide your group in half and create two concentric circles: one inner circle and one outer circle. The students in the outer circle should face inside and the students in the inner circle should face outside. Each inner circle student will pair up with an outer circle student. Students may stand, sit on the floor, or use chairs for this activity.
1). Hand out the index cards and pens for each student
2). Ask the students to think about their individual values and what makes up their identity.
3). Instruct them to write one value or identity on each index card, with the goal of having around 10 index cards. Some example of these values:
- Race (Hispanic, Arabic, Asian, Black)
- Religion (Muslim, Christian, Atheist)
- Occupation (Engineer, student, teacher)
- Family (sister, brother, mother,)
- Hobbies (athletics, cooking, reading)
- Health (healthy, immobile, diabetic)
- Socio-economic (wealthy, middle-class, low-income)
4). Once everyone has their values and identities written down, have the students share with their first partner why they chose to write down the values they did.
5). After the discussion is complete, ask all students to rip up one of their cards. This part of the activity gives participants an opportunity to reflect on how they prioritize their identities. Ripping up the card should help the participants imagine living without that part of their identity.
6). After the participants rip up one card, the outer circle will rotate one partner to the right. Everyone should have a new partner now.
7). The students will now discuss with their partner why and how they chose the card to rip up.
8). The process continues until all participants are each left with one card – their most important value.
9). Debrief the activity:
- How did it feel to do this activity?
- What was easy? What was challenging?
- What groups/categories did folks pick?
- Is there any category that you would identify as your “core” identity?
- What similarities and differences did emerge?
- Did you identify any environments where one identity was more salient than another?
- What invisible identities (inside/outside identities) became visible as a result of this exercise? Any thoughts about this?
- How/why are these categories helpful or not helpful?